# Is the average stock taking the lead, or just falling more slowly?

Canonical URL: https://mrkts.gg/desk/thesis-thursday-2026-11-05
Last updated: Nov 5, 2026, 11:43 AM ET

Thesis thursday · Published Nov 5, 2026, 11:43 AM ET

> The equal-weight S&P closed at a one-year high Wednesday and is down only about 2.0% today while the Nasdaq proxy falls about 4.5%. Friday's jobs report and Tuesday's inflation data decide whether that is a real handoff or just a softer landing.

## In short

- The average stock catching up is heating again: the equal-weight S&P is down about 2.0% today against about 4.5% for the Nasdaq proxy, a day after its highest close in a year.
- Bull: it is up about 5.3% since Sep 30 while the Nasdaq proxy is down about 10.7%. Bear: small caps are down about 2.9% today, so the rest of the market is falling too, just less.
- Friday's 8:30 AM ET jobs report, forecast at 55,000, then Tuesday's inflation report test whether the lead holds once the market bounces.

## Key numbers

- RSP: −1.96% (today, 11:40 AM ET)
- SPY: −2.89% (today, 11:40 AM ET)
- QQQ: −4.54% (today, 11:40 AM ET)
- IWM: −2.92% (today, small caps fall too)
- RSP SINCE SEP 30: +5.25% (to 11:40 AM ET today)
- QQQ SINCE SEP 30: −10.71% (to 11:40 AM ET today)
- NEXT TEST: Nov 6 (jobs report, 8:30 AM ET, forecast 55K)
- NVDA EARNINGS: Nov 17 (after the close, implied about 9.6%)

The average stock catching up is the story that flipped twice this week, and today puts it to a hard test. As of about 11:40 AM ET the Nasdaq proxy is down about 4.5% and the chip ETF about 8.0% as chipmakers keep selling. The equal-weight S&P, which gives every company in the index the same weight, is down about 2.0%, beating the S&P proxy's −2.9% by about 0.9 points. The question is whether money is moving into the rest of the market, or just leaving it more slowly.

## The bull case

The gap has been building for five weeks, not one day. Since the Sep 30 close the equal-weight S&P is up about 5.3%, while the S&P proxy is down about 2.4% and the Nasdaq proxy about 10.7%. On Wednesday it closed at 223.33, its highest close in a year, while the Nasdaq proxy is still about 13% below its Oct 6 close. This week it is up about 0.3% even after today, against about −1.5% for the S&P proxy, and regional banks are up about 1.6%. The fear in options sits in big tech: through about 11:40 AM ET traders paid a net $156 million for Nasdaq proxy puts, while a net $19 million of small-cap puts were sold. Posts say equal weight "hit new highs ahead of price" as breadth widened on Wednesday.

*Chart: Line chart of percent change since the Sep 30 close. The equal-weight S&P (RSP) is up 5.3% at 11:40 AM ET Nov 5 after peaking near +7.4% at the Nov 4 close. Small caps (IWM) are down 0.8%, the S&P proxy (SPY) is down 2.4% and the Nasdaq proxy (QQQ) is down 10.7%. Five weeks in, the equal-weight index is ahead and the Nasdaq proxy is far behind, though small caps have not kept up.*

## The bear case

Falling less is not the same as leading. The equal-weight S&P is still down about 2.0% today, and small caps are down about 2.9%, as much as the S&P proxy, so the rest of the market is not acting as a shelter. Small caps are still about 0.8% below their Sep 30 close, which means most of the catch-up has come from big tech falling, not from smaller companies rising. Across all listed options, net call premium is about −$527 million through 11:40 AM ET, a broad pullback rather than a rotation trade, and the vol proxy is up about 17%. Posts caution that equal weight at highs with weak chips has historically meant "softer SPY/QQQ forwards, not an all-clear."

## What would settle it

Three dates. Friday at 8:30 AM ET brings the October jobs report, with payrolls forecast at 55,000 after 29,000 and unemployment at 4.2%. A steady number helps the banks, factories and retailers that fill the equal-weight index, while a weak one tests whether small caps can hold. Tuesday, Nov 10 at 8:30 AM ET brings October consumer prices, after core prices rose 0.3% in September. Then Nvidia reports after the close on Nov 17, with options pricing a move of about 9.6%. The story ends if big tech retakes the lead for weeks while equal weight lags. Until then, the equal-weight S&P beating the S&P proxy on jobs day and through the inflation report keeps it alive.

## Desk read

The evidence leans bull on the relative story, with moderate confidence. Five weeks of the equal-weight index beating the big-cap ones, a one-year high on Wednesday, and fear that sits in Nasdaq options rather than small-cap ones all point to a real broadening. The caution is that today the whole market is falling and small caps are falling with it, so the average stock is winning a relative race in a losing market. If it keeps its lead when the S&P proxy bounces, that is a handoff. If it only wins on down days, it is a softer landing. This is a read of the evidence, not a trade call.

## Scenarios

- If If jobs land near the 55,000 forecast and equal weight keeps beating the S&P proxy into the inflation report: The handoff story firms up, with banks, factories and retailers doing more of the lifting than big tech.
- If If the chip selling spreads and equal weight falls as fast as the S&P proxy: The catch-up turns out to be a softer landing rather than a new leader, and the story cools.

---

Get the Desk's daily market feature by email: https://mrkts.gg/newsletter?ref=ai&src=desk-thesis-thursday-2026-11-05

AI-assisted commentary. Not investment advice.
